-
Bradin Cormack's and Carla Mazzio's Book Use, Book
Theory: 1500-1700 is based on an exhibition organised for the Special
Collections Research Centre at the University of Chicago Library in Spring
2005. The volume is a valuable contribution to the growing field of book
history, and situates itself at the interface between the social and material
dimensions of early modern book production. The idea of 'use' is crucial
in this respect, both as a principle of selection and arrangement and
as a broader methodological framework: in the period between 1500 and
1700, the authors argue, "printed books were primarily understood as instrumental,
directing their readers and users, within particular fields of practice
and knowledge, toward some more or less practical end" (4). The early
modern book is here presented not just as a material object but as a practical
tool that mediates and helps shape contemporary systems of knowledge
in the emergent professional disciplines of law and medicine, in the literary,
religious and scientific spheres, and, importantly, in the more mundane
world of how-to manuals that instructed their readers in everyday activities
such as cooking, praying and travelling.
-
For Cormack and Mazzio, the concept of using a book engages
two kinds of practice, one "textual", the other "worldly". Worldly practice
represents a whole range of strategies that enable readers to apply a
book's lessons to real life. Textual practice, meanwhile, refers to the
technological innovations of the early printed book that encourage the
reader's active physical engagement and thus transform contact with the
text into a form of "doing or action" (3). Johan Remmelin's anatomical
atlas A Survey of the Microcosme (1702) embodies this relationship
between the material text and the world of professional activity: its
interactive, layered illustrations invite the reader to replicate and
rehearse the process of dissection by folding back consecutive bodily
surfaces. In the act of moving, physically and textually, from skin to
bone, the reader simultaneously performs and anticipates the processes
of discovery that were being codified in contemporary anatomical discourses.
-
Book Use, Book Theory is itself a highly desirable
material object beautifully produced and lavishly illustrated with
high-quality black-and-white reproductions. The volume starts with a 30-page
introduction, followed by a sizeable selection of exhibition items (75
in total). The introduction is a substantial and ambitious piece, taking
full account of existing work in the field and setting out the aims of
the exhibition with admirable clarity. The catalogue itself is divided
into five main sections, which are in turn organised into several subcategories.
The first section, "Technologies of Use", explores the material strategies
that define a book's use value from customised bindings and textual
annotations that signify ownership and readerly appropriation, to decisions
about format and layout that could determine a book's position in the
professional marketplace. "Parts and Wholes" focuses on prefaces, tables
of contents, indexes and diagrammatic schemes visual grids that
help readers to navigate books but also provide larger-scale models for
processing information and organising knowledge. This is a richly rewarding
section, not least because it points to some of the downsides of practical
utility: Ramist charts and diagrams were frequently seen as intellectual
shortcuts that inhibited rather than facilitated a genuinely rigorous
engagement with the material at hand. Section Three, on "The How-to Book",
also offers numerous interesting insights, but at times it seems as though
the examples struggle to support the burden of the argument. It is easy
to see, for instance, how a meat-carving manual positions "readers as
actors" and requires them "to actualize knowledge by performing it", but
does this inevitably lead to "the cultivation of personhood" or even "a
transformation of identity" (79)? (A rousing thought for all assemblers
of flat pack furniture, though.) The final two sections examine the different
ways in which books invited their readers to think beyond the printed
text. "Dimensional Thinking" draws its strongest examples from the fields
of geometry, astronomy and anatomy to illustrate how physical features
such as pop-ups, foldouts and movable discs encouraged readers to imagine
a space beyond the two-dimensional confines of the page, while "Taking
Liberties" focuses on instances of book use that strain the boundaries
of decorum and material representation midwifery manuals deliberately
misinterpreted as pornography, or treatises on music struggling to evoke
the idea and sensation of sound.
-
It is at this point that the volume (perhaps all too
briefly) moves out from its self-imposed heuristic boundaries a
world where thought is radically embodied and where 'reading' can at times
seem like the poor cousin of vigorous material engagement and invites
reflections on aspects of the book that reach beyond its physical uses.
What is done with those reflections is, of course, up to the reader (or
user), but putting interpretation back in the frame might be one valuable
way forward.